After two years in business, weekly featured menus aren't possible. I'll do my best to offer them as often as I can. Click below to see what's available. Follow me on Instagram/Facebook to get the most up-to-date treat news!
Majority of the fruit for my jams is sourced from the Newark Farmers market so that means the ingredients are fresh and local! I'm always experimenting with. new flavors and trying new ingredients so my selection of jams is always changing! Some of the jams I offer are white peach vanilla, strawberry, blueberry lavender, blueberry peach, vanilla pear berry, apple butter and more! My in stock jams are always available to purchase through the online store or at the Newark Farmers' Market. Send me a message if you need a weekday pick up!
Tried and true crowd-pleasers
Traditional chocolate chip with a twist. A slight crunch, but chewy on the inside, with flake sea salt to finish it off.
Melt in your mouth butter cookies rolled in cinnamon and sugar.
Magical Box Bakery signature cookie. Gooey red velvet butter cookie swirled with a traditional sugar cookie.
Oatmeal raisin, hold the raisins and add chocolate chips!!! Chocolate oatey goodness with a hint of cinnamon.
Soft cake-like sugar cookies filled and topped with sprinkles!
This cookie is an adaptation of the rumored $250 high-end department store cafe chocolate chip cookie. Chewy center, pecans, chocolate chips AND grated milk chocolate, what's not to love!?
Soft cookie full of peanut butter flavor! It's a pretty traditional peanut butter cookie, rolled in sugar.
If you love Earl Grey tea, YOU WILL LOVE THESE COOKIES! They're a pretty traditional sugar cookie, rolled in sugar before baking but they're made with earl grey tea! Don't be scared away by the lavender, it's only 1/2 a teaspoon for about 12 cookies so it's just a hint.
. These are my take on a monster cookie. They are baked with peanut butter, semi sweet chocolate chips, rolled oats, and pastel M&Ms.
Super soft cake-like cookies with an Oreo buttercream filling. Because these sandwich cookies are so large, they're offered in quantities of 4 and 8.
Super soft short cake sugar cookies and strawberry buttercream made with locally sourced, organic, strawberries. Finally, the cookies are finished off with Biscoff cookie crumbles.
Super soft cake-like chocolate fudge cookies with graham cracker buttercream filling and a marshmallow fluff center. Because these sandwich cookies are so large, they're offered in quantities of 4 and 8.
If a brownie grew up to be a cookie, this would be it. Soft, fudgey cookies with locally sourced Guittard chocolate chips and organic, fair trade cocoa powder.
Just like the original s'mores sandwich cookies, these are made with a soft, chocolate fudge, cake-like cookie. However, instead of graham cracker buttercream and marshmallow fluff, these have a handcrafted graham cracker marshmallow inside!
*sold individually, in heat sealed bioplastic bags
Soft and chewy chocolate chip cookie with semi-sweet chocolate chips and high altitude Costa Rican coffee.
When we went on vacation to Costa Rica, we toured a coffee plantation and roasting facility with the owner Matias. The weather was horrible so we got trapped there, the roads were too muddy to drive. We talked, drank pineapple smoothies, and roasted coffee all day. It was the best. To this day, we still get our coffee from him, shipped from Costa Rica.
Please send an inquiry through my contact form for a quote
From scratch marshmallows are a game changer! Soft, creamy, and no extra preservatives.
Birthday cake, lavender honey, brown sugar & honey, green tea & honey, apple cider, cookies & cream, brownie batter are just SOME of the awesome flavor combos!
Mallow donuts can be made with any flavor combo! They can be customized with light, dark, or white chocolate and the sprinkle bobos are endless!
Learn more about the causes we support
Soft sugar cookies with a hint of almond. During the month of June a percentage of our PRIDE cookies will be donated to The Human Rights campaign
Decorated sugar cookies in response to the anti LGBTQIA+ legislation in Florida and Texas. The Human Rights campaign
Soft vanilla almond sugar cookies decorated with royal icing.
Profits are being donated to Polska Akcja Humanitarna (PAK) helping Ukrainian refugees in Poland.
Pre-made dough, ready to bake at home
*Sandwich cookies not offered as a frozen dough
-Please contact me for specific pricing. Price will include a $1 jar deposit. If you reorder, and bring your jar back, you get $2 off your next order.
-All frozen cookie dough orders will come with baking and storing instructions
*only available for pick up at the Magnolia St. location
Deliciouly sweet loaves of goodness
Towering pumpkin loaf with a crispy cinnamon-sugar crust
Tender poppyseed muffins with a crunch of coarse sugar on top, and a sweet almond glaze
Gorgeous and delicious celebration breads
1.25 lb sweet brioche loaf with twists of Nutella®️
1.25 lb sweet brioche loaf with twists of cinnamon and sugar
Plush little cakes for one (special order only)
Tender vanilla cake with sweet American vanilla bean buttercream
Birthday cake flavored cake with sprinkles, topped with traditional American butter cream, and, you guessed it, more sprinkles!
*Multicolored icing available for an added fee
Rich red velvet flavor with a tender crumb.